“What would Jesus do?”
The answer to that question often depends on who you ask. It’s a question that fits nicely into the relativistic mind of our age. It allows each of us to thoughtfully rub our chins, look up at the sky and say, “Well, I believe Jesus would…” So, the question is really just Jiminy Cricket’s “follow your conscience” line wearing a Christian mask. It is relativism presented as religion. Whatever answer you come up with is as good as anyone else’s answer as long as we are all “sincere.”
Often, the honest answer to the question “What would Jesus do?” is “I really don’t know.” His disciples lived with him for three years and Jesus constantly kept them surprised and guessing. Why are we so convinced that we have Jesus pegged? For example, it astounds me when celebrities claim to know what Jesus would or would not approve of, as if being a famous celebrity makes one an authority on the mind of Christ.
When we ask, “What would Jesus do?” we can only think and act hypothetically. We can only speculate and take our best guess. Maybe we’re helping, maybe we’re doing harm. What if we decide to do the exact opposite of what Jesus would actually do? Our world faces daily situations for which there are no explicit instructions in the Bible. Dealing in general, biblical principles does not always provide enough specifics. Asking what Jesus would do often doesn’t help much.
Perhaps a more helpful question is, “What did Jesus do?” There are documented answers to that question. In terms of what our world faces today, an important answer is, “Jesus established an authoritative, teaching Church to guide us and to spiritually feed us.” In the midst of all the confusion over what Jesus would do, we have a Church to inform us of what we as followers of Jesus in this present day are to do and what we are not to do.
I sometimes hear people defend immorality by stating that the Bible is silent or ambiguous about certain modern day issues. Of course it is! Jesus never told his disciples to write a book to instruct us on every possible, future, moral issue. Jesus established a Church (only one Church) with the authority to provide us with those instructions on faith and morals. Jesus did not establish multiple church denominations to speculate and argue about what He might or might not do. Men established those churches (some very recently).
God is not the author of confusion. Jesus did not leave us with a Bible, the Holy Spirit and hypothetical questions about what He would do. He left us with His Church, guided by the Holy Spirit, to lead us into all truth. Does this mean we always have every answer to every question? No. Does it mean we put it to a vote when we are confused about what Jesus would do? No (Christianity is not a democracy). It means that by following His Church we are following Jesus. We are to strive for obedience to the faith, not speculation.
It comes down to trust (i.e. faith). Either we trust with all our heart that Jesus knew what He was doing when He established the Church (trust what He did), or we try to constantly change the Church to conform to our speculations about what Jesus would do (lean on our own understanding and feelings).